The MMC Controversy in Texas PI Law
If you practice personal injury law in Texas, you have heard the term "Medical Management Company" — and you may have good reason to be cautious about it. Medical Management Companies have been at the center of significant legal controversy in Texas, including disciplinary actions, bar complaints, and at least one high-profile attorney disbarment case.
Understanding what an MMC is — and what distinguishes a legitimate coordination network from one — is essential for any Houston PI attorney making medical referrals.
What Is a Medical Management Company?
A Medical Management Company (in the context that creates legal risk) typically refers to an arrangement where:
1. A business entity (often owned by or closely connected to an attorney or investor) directs the flow of PI patients to specific medical providers.
2. The entity receives compensation based on a percentage of the medical bills generated by those patients.
3. The entity controls clinical decisions, billing practices, or documentation to maximize lien values.
4. The arrangement creates a financial interest for the attorney in the medical bills — not just the case outcome.
The legal problems with this structure are serious. Texas barratry law prohibits direct or indirect financial arrangements that create improper incentives in the attorney-client relationship. When an attorney's compensation flows through medical bills generated by providers they effectively control or receive kickbacks from, multiple violations may be triggered.
The Texas State Bar and the Texas Supreme Court have taken an increasingly aggressive stance on MMC arrangements. Several Houston-area attorneys have faced discipline for MMC involvement.
What Makes a Coordination Network Different
Next Level Chiro Care is structured specifically to avoid every element of the problematic MMC model:
Independent clinic ownership. All 20 clinics in our network are independently owned and operated by their licensed chiropractors. We have no ownership stake, partial ownership, management control, or financial interest in any clinic's operations. The clinics were operating before our network existed and would continue operating if the network dissolved tomorrow.
No percentage-based compensation. Our coordination fee is a flat administrative rate paid by clinics for scheduling coordination, intake management, and documentation follow-up. It is not calculated as a percentage of medical bills, treatment volume, or case settlements. There is no financial incentive for us to maximize treatment or billing.
Full clinical autonomy. Treating physicians make all clinical decisions. We do not direct treatment plans, specify billing codes, require minimum visit counts, or have any role in clinical documentation. The doctor treats what the doctor determines needs treatment, for as long as is clinically indicated.
No attorney financial interest. We are not owned by any attorney, law firm, or person connected to a law firm. No attorney receives compensation, referral fees, or any financial benefit from our operations. The network was created to solve a logistics problem — patient compliance — not to create a revenue stream for legal professionals.
One-directional referrals. Referrals flow from attorneys to us. We never contact accident victims, solicit cases, or refer cases to attorneys. We exist to serve cases that attorneys have already engaged, not to generate new cases for attorneys.
Why the Distinction Matters Legally
For attorneys evaluating whether to use any medical coordination service, the key questions are:
Does the arrangement create a financial interest in the medical bills? If you receive any compensation, fee-sharing, or discount arrangement connected to the medical treatment your clients receive, you likely have a barratry issue.
Does anyone with an interest in legal fees control clinical decisions? If the entity directing medical treatment has any ownership, management, or financial connection to the legal side of the case, scrutinize the structure carefully.
Is the coordination fee tied to treatment volume? Flat fees for administrative services are structurally different from percentage arrangements. A flat fee for scheduling coordination is hard to characterize as an improper inducement. A 15% fee on all medical bills generated by referred patients is not.
Who owns the clinics? Independent ownership by licensed physicians is the clearest signal that clinical decisions are being made by clinicians, not by people with financial interests in maximizing treatment volume.
The Practical Compliance Posture
At Next Level Chiro Care, our structure reflects a deliberate effort to stay far from the line that has gotten other arrangements in trouble:
- Independent clinic ownership verified for all 20 providers
- Flat coordination fee with no volume or value component
- Zero financial connection to any law firm or attorney
- No solicitation of accident victims or referral of cases to attorneys
- Full clinical autonomy for treating physicians
- Transportation provided under documented anti-kickback safe harbor criteria
We encourage any attorney with compliance concerns to review our structure with their own counsel before referring. We will provide any documentation requested to facilitate that review.
The Bottom Line
Medical Management Companies became problematic when the financial incentives of the legal and medical sides of PI cases became inappropriately entangled. The solution is not to avoid all medical coordination — it is to use coordination arrangements that maintain clear separation between clinical decisions and legal financial interests.
Next Level Chiro Care was built with that separation as a foundational design principle. We solve a logistics problem. We do not create a financial arrangement. And we are happy to explain our structure to any attorney who wants to understand it before they refer.
If you have questions about our compliance structure, contact us at 832-691-6760 or admin@nextlevelchirocares.com. We will connect you directly with our compliance documentation.
Put This Into Practice
One referral. 60 seconds. See what 95% compliance looks like.
See How We're Structured